Adapting literary works for the screen is always an exercise
fraught with peril, but director David Cronenberg took the ultimate
plunge with Naked Lunch. His source material was the infamous
counterculture novel by William S. Burroughs, a surreal tsunami
of paranoid, stream-of-consciousness wordplay that was generally
considered to be unfilmable. In penning the screenplay, however,
Cronenberg decided to fuse elements of Naked Lunch with "tones
and tropes" from other Burroughs books (including Junkie, Exterminator and Queer),
while also incorporating biographical aspects of the author's
life. Although this complex undertaking was not fully appreciated
by critics or audiences - Cronenberg concedes that Naked Lunch is "certainly
not a mainstream film in any sense" - Criterion's two-disc
special edition will be of interest to anyone who wants to learn
more about Burroughs and his oeuvre.
Indeed, the film's dual audio commentary (featuring Cronenberg
and actor Peter Weller, who plays Burroughs' alter ego, Bill
Lee) is essential listening for anyone who is not already familiar
with the author or his writings. (Those without a working knowledge
of Burroughs, or at least an appreciation of his pitch-black
humor, may well find the movie's bizarre narrative to be off-putting
or even impenetrable.) Cronenberg details his methods with openness
and his usual droll intellect, but Weller more than holds his
own; the actor clearly took this commentary seriously and came
to the table well prepared, and his insights are consistently
informative and perceptive. Likening Burroughs to a "prophet" and
a "shaman," Weller notes that the author used drugs
as a metaphor for those things that "each of us, individually
and sociologically, are hooked on - [the things] that we obsess
on that keep us from ever knowing ... ourselves." Assessing
Cronenberg's cinematic worldview, the actor observes that the
unifying motif was "the solitary sojourn of a melancholiac,
of someone who felt a penetrating sadness for something or other
that they didn't think they could overcome."
An adventurous thespian, Weller found the combination of these
two sensibilities irresistible, although he initially felt that
Cronenberg's screenplay might be excessively dense in its fetishistic
attention to detail. To be sure, Cronenberg shares many obsessions
with Burroughs (physical mutation, polymorphous perversity and
a fixation on manipulation and control, to name a few), and his
splicing of their interests resulted in a film that pushes the
limits of "literary cinema."
Cronenberg initially planned to shoot the bulk of the film on
location in the Middle East, but the outbreak of the first Gulf
War led him to scrap that plan and create the story's mystical
mindscape within Toronto soundstages. The filmmaker justifies
the more controlled use of stages by noting that the story's
main setting - Interzone, a hallucinatory hybrid of Tangier and
New York City - is "a state of mind and not a real place." He
respectfully credits the physical realization of this nefarious
setting to both production designer Carol Spier and cinematographer
Peter Suschitzky, ASC, BSC. Noting that he has collaborated with
Suschitzky on every picture since 1988's Dead Ringers,
Cronenberg calls the cinematographer "a fantastic lighting
cameraman," adding, "Peter's work is just so subtle.
Often I can barely get to the actors when we're shooting a close-up,
because there are so many cutters and flags and ... light-diffusing
devices in the way. But the result is beautifully three-dimensional,
sculptural, subtle lighting, which is what I absolutely love
about working with Peter."
The handsome, faultless transfer on this DVD preserves the lushness
of Suschitzky's images, which render the tale's phantasmagorical
world primarily in tones of forest green, chocolate brown and
jaundiced yellow. Some of the film's creature effects may seem
a bit quaint by today's standards (the talking-bug typewriters
and narcotic-secreting "mugwumps" required intricate,
hands-on construction and puppeteering), but both the director
and Weller express their fond preference for the old-school methods,
which allowed the performers to interact directly with these
fantastic creations.
The package includes a wealth of background information on the
production and Burroughs. A 32-page booklet features essays by
film critic Janet Maslin, journalist Chris Rodley and culture
critic Gary Indiana, as well as a piece by Burroughs; Rodley's
TV documentary Naked Making Lunch puts the cinematic undertaking
in lucid perspective; and an illustrated essay by Cinefex magazine
editor Jody Duncan details the movie's special effects. The second
disc serves up a collection of 20th Century Fox's original marketing
materials (including the exceptionally artful and eye-catching
theatrical trailer), a gallery of photos from the film shoot,
and selected photos from the collection of Beat poet and Burroughs
friend Allen Ginsberg, whose personal notes precede each shot.
Last but not least is an additional audio treat: recordings of
Burroughs reading select passages from Naked Lunch.
All in all, this DVD excursion goes well beyond the film itself
to offer what amounts to a master class in the weird, wired world
of William S. Burroughs. It's a trip well worth the taking for
those who enjoy provocative detours from conventional thinking.
- Stephen Pizzello