Loosely based on the truncated, train-wreck life of blues/rock belter Janis
Joplin, The Rose stars Bette Midler as a mercurial,
hard-drinking diva whose inner demons drive her into a
self-destructive spiral. The well-cast Midler (who earned
an Oscar nomination for her dramatic-feature debut) tears
through the film like a Tasmanian devil, capturing her
character's exhilarating highs and soul-crushing lows in
a series of interludes that run the gamut from Dionysian
decadence to heartbreaking pathos. The result is a richly
detailed character study that captures the both the energy
and nihilism of the Sixties rock scene.
This unblinking, warts-and-all indictment of the showbiz
lifestyle was shot by the esteemed Vilmos Zsigmond, ASC, whose evocative cinematography manages to
convey a full range of moods and emotions. Zsigmond renders
the film's dynamic concert scenes in vibrant hues that
bolster Midler's electrifying performances, but artfully
tones things down during the narrative's quieter, more
contemplative scenes.
In an audio commentary for this new DVD, director Mark Rydell testifies that he was "really lucky" to
have Zsigmond as his director
of photography because the show posed some formidable challenges
- including the complex logistics of the concert scenes,
which were filmed live in front of real audiences comprised
of up to 6,000 extras (or "atmospheric artists," as Rydell graciously refers to them). Nine cameras were used
to record the onstage action, and Zsigmond's stature
allowed the production to recruit some top pros to operate
them: ASC members Bobby Byrne, Conrad Hall, Jan Kiesser,
Laszlo Kovacs, Michael Margulies, Owen Roizman and
Haskell Wexler all took up positions, along with Steve Lydecker and
David Meyers. According to Rydell,
the result of this
documentary approach was "a
certain kind of power and passion and vitality that would
never be achievable if somebody other than the actual performer
was singing and they were just lip-syncing. I always find
that intolerable." The filmmakers also wisely avoided
constant cuts and flashy editing, which keeps the focus
on Midler's intense theatrics and formidable charisma.
Although it would have been nice to hear some comments
from Zsigmond on this disc, Rydell offers
some heartfelt appreciation of the cinematographer's outstanding
work: "I'm always impressed by the work of Vilmos Zsigmond, who lit all these scenes with such care and reality.
It was just wonderful to see; every day when we went to
dailies, we were thrilled. I must tell you that we knew
from day one that we had something special and that it
was going to last."
The film does indeed offer its share of memorable moments:
the Rose being chastised by a righteous country singer
(Harry Dean Stanton) who doesn't appreciate her covers
of his tunes; the diva's escalating confrontations with
her domineering manager (Alan Bates), who would like to
squash his star's budding romance with an earthy chauffeur
(Frederic Forrest, in an Oscar-nominated effort); the sight
of Midler being serenaded by a club full of drag queens;
and the singer's painful return to her hometown, where
she finds that nothing much has changed since her unhappy
adolescence.
This transfer is decent, if a bit uneven in spots. The
concert scenes are almost uniformly pristine, but other
sequences suffer from excessive grain and occasional artifacts.
Overall, though, the disc manages to preserve the character
of Zsigmond's cinematography,
which was softened by his use of heavy diffusion.
Aside from Rydell's commentary
track, the disc's only extra is a theatrical trailer. But
fans of both Joplin and Midler (as well as Zsigmond)
will find this DVD of considerable interest.
-- Stephen Pizzello